Appeals court rules doctor's estate can sue hospital, attending physician

 

YAKIMA, Wash. -- A lawsuit accusing Sunnyside Community Hospital of negligence in the emergency treatment of one of its own physicians who later died may go to trial after all.

The state Court of Appeals on Tuesday sent back a wrongful death lawsuit to Yakima County Superior Court, overruling a judge who dismissed the case nearly two years ago.

The lawsuit alleges that in 2006, Dr. Terri Grant, an emergency room physician at Sunnyside Community Hospital, was negligent in treating Dr. Sandra Wilson's existing brain condition with migraine headache medicine, worsening the problem and causing her death.

Wilson, an internist at the hospital, died at the age of 35.

Her father, Dr. David Wilson of Missouri, sued Grant and the hospital as the personal representative of his daughter's estate for an unspecified amount to compensate for the loss of her wages, payment of medical bills and pain and suffering.

Attorneys for the hospital and Grant argued that the estate was not entitled to any recovery because Sandra Wilson wasn't survived by any beneficiaries recognized by law, such as a spouse, children or other dependent relatives.

Hospital attorneys also claimed that the hospital is not liable because Grant was a contracted physician, not an employee on the payroll.

In a 2009 summary judgment, Superior Court Judge James Lust agreed with the hospital and Grant.

Tuesday's opinion reverses part of that summary judgment, and says that a jury should decide if the estate deserves any damages for economic loss, such as forgone wages and payment of medical bills. The appellate opinion agreed with Lust, however, that David Wilson is not eligible for pain and suffering.

The opinion does not rule on the negligence claim.

David Wilson's attorney said the summary judgment, and therefore the reversal, on the question of an estate claiming damages in medical malpractice cases is unusual.

"At least in my experience, summary judgment ... is pretty rare," said Mark Kamitomo of Spokane, who specializes in medical malpractice lawsuits.

Attorneys for the hospital and Grant said summary judgments and reversals happen frequently.

"There's nothing unusual about what happened here," said Jerry Aiken of Yakima, who represents the hospital.

Grant and hospital officials have 30 days to appeal to the state Supreme Court. Neither of them have decided, their attorneys said.

Medical Malpractice Articles - News


Appeals court rules doctor's estate can sue hospital, attending physician

The opinion does not rule on the negligence claim. David Wilson's attorney said the summary judgment, and therefore the reversal, on the question of an estate claiming damages in medical malpractice cases is unusual. "At least in my experience,



Court wrestles with bizarre malpractice case

MARIETTA — After a mentally ill Georgia man was charged with stabbing his mother to death amid a psychotic rage, his father took a peculiar step that has so far divided Georgia courts: He filed a medical malpractice lawsuit



Burned by the Courts
Burned by the Courts

As Tom Baker's exhaustive research makes clear the idea that medical malpractice suits explain the rising costs to the American medical system are just as fictitious as most tort tales. Lawsuits, though, make a convenient scapegoat that can be used to



West Virginia court upholds medical malpractice damage cap

West Virginia has upheld a 2003 law capping damages for pain and suffering at $250000 (or $500000 in more serious cases), much to the delight of the state's medical association. Former Governor Bob Wise (DW. Va.) signed the cap into law in an effort to



High Court to Hear Cases in Cobb

A psychiatrist is appealing a decision by the Georgia Court of Appeals, which ruled that a jury should decide whether he committed medical malpractice by discontinuing a man's anti-psychotic medication. Soon after the medication stopped,




Medical Malpractice Attorney Helps in Malpractice Lawsuits ...

A person requesting for medical attention should receive the appropriate treatment. However, there are times when a person is not able to acquire the efficiency with medical staff or organization. This results to medical errors whereby the patient searching for appropriate medical attention undergoes the outcomes of carelessness. The most common irresponsible works include delivery stress, prescription error, medical harm, delayed diagnosis, and unlawful death. Such incidents would affect your family in financial terms, mental aspects, or both. Medial practitioners should provide care to the best of their skills. When they commit medical errors, they should face the cost of their actions and this can be done with the legal help of a Maryland medical malpractice attorney.

If you think you are a victim of health care negligence, then you need to try to get impartiality. Acquire the appropriate claims by way of assistance by competent medical malpractice lawyer that will be very willing to give you support from start to finish. Just like any other litigations filed in court, your lawyer should be very knowledgeable in the field of medical malpractice in order to properly fight your civil rights for your benefit.

When you or your family suffered from medical carelessness, do not think twice to seek advice and support of the most capable legal professional. A medical malpractice lawyer can straightaway do the work, answer your questions and guide you during the court proceedings. The sooner you contact a lawyer the faster it will be for your lawyer to file a medical malpractice suit. The health care providers are held accountable of the carelessness which led to the problem or death.

If a medical professional does not perform in accordance to the criteria of his job, then it is appropriate to take legal action against the person. This is to stop the incident from happening again. Lawsuits regarding health care are very technical and extremely complicated. It will always call for health care professional witnesses, important medical evidence and other parties such as insurance providers.

Getting the best attorney for your case is a crucial step in winning a medical malpractice lawsuit. You should get someone who has rich experience on the subject matter provided that this suit is lengthy, tough and high-priced. After you get a reputable Maryland medical malpractice attorney, you are assured that the lawsuit brings a very good battle without having the probability of being dismissed. When your case wins, you can get all the compensation for the health care expenses, lost earnings, therapy expenses, and others.


Twitter

Jada Dalby Medical Malpractice is a Leading Cause of Death in US: We have numerous other articles written on this very subj...


Dwana Delatte Medical Malpractice is a Leading Cause of Death in US: We have numerous other articles written on this very subj...


Gabriela Pals Medical Malpractice is a Leading Cause of Death in US: We have numerous other articles written on this very subj...


Brittanie Bivens Medical Malpractice is a Leading Cause of Death in US: We have numerous other articles written on this very subj...


Noriko Zeff Medical Malpractice is a Leading Cause of Death in US: We have numerous other articles written on this very subj...


Medical Malpractice Articles - Bookshelf

Medical malpractice, law, tactics, and ethics

Medical malpractice, law, tactics, and ethics

Frank M. McClellan illustrates the multitude of considerations that impact the merit of each case, never losing sight of the importance of preserving human ...

Medical malpractice, a physician's sourcebook

Medical malpractice, a physician's sourcebook

A comprehensive presentation of the origin, nature, and ramifications of the medical malpractice litigation crisis, as well as possible solutions and ...

The medical malpractice myth

The medical malpractice myth

Tom Baker offers a stunning dismantling of familiar stereotypes about medical malpractice lawsuits by presenting research that completely disproves the myths of ...

Medical Malpractice and the American Jury, Confronting the Myths about Jury Incompetence, Deep Pockets, and Outrageous Damage Awards

Medical Malpractice and the American Jury, Confronting the Myths about Jury Incompetence, Deep Pockets, and Outrageous Damage Awards

In this landmark book, Neil Vidmar looks beyond the common perceptions of medical malpractice litigation and finds a system that is fair, impartial, and ...

Avoiding medical malpractice, a physician's guide to the law

Avoiding medical malpractice, a physician's guide to the law

Avoiding Medical Malpractice: A Physician's Guide to the Law, combines real-world knowledge of both the law and clinical medicine, resulting in a reader ...

Check Information Directory


List of Medical Malpractice Articles - WrongDiagnosis.com
Medical information on symptoms, diagnosis, and misdiagnosis of more than 2,000 ... The following specific articles relate to various aspects of medical malpractice: ...

Legal: Medical Malpractice Article Category
EzineArticles.com allows expert authors in hundreds of niche fields to get massive levels of exposure in exchange for the submission of their quality original articles.

Articles | Furr & Henshaw | South Carolina
Our South Carolina medical malpractice lawyers have the compassion, skill and resources to make a difference. Call 800-849-2525 today.

Medical Malpractice Articles
Articles on medical malpractice, effects on patients, physicians, health costs -- alternatives to the tort system and tort reform.

Medical Malpractice Cases
This article highlights some close call medical malpractice cases, of patients that have ... These medical malpractice cases alternate between horrifying and hilarious. ...